Methodology
Every product on Foreverish is scored on five dimensions, 1–10 each. A product cannot publish until every dimension has at least one cited source — a fetched URL, the claim it supports, and the quoted text. If a dimension has no citation, the product doesn't appear on the site. That rule is enforced structurally, not by memory: sources live in their own table, tied to a dimension, so an unsourced claim has nowhere to live.
The five dimensions
- Warranty
- Length and real coverage. A "lifetime" warranty covering only manufacturing defects scores below a 10-year warranty covering wear.
- Parts Availability
- Can you buy spares, and for how long after discontinuation.
- Repairability
- Can an owner or an independent shop repair it, with published schematics, standard fasteners and resoleable construction.
- Company Stability
- Age, ownership history, whether an acquisition changed the product. Captures the "used to be good" problem.
- Owner Longevity
- Documented real-world lifespan evidence, not marketing claims. Its source must be one the manufacturer does not control.
Why owner longevity is different
Four of the five dimensions can legitimately cite the manufacturer: a warranty page is the authority on its own warranty, and a service page is the authority on what service is offered. Owner longevity is the one dimension that is evidence about the maker rather than from it, so a manufacturer-hosted source cannot satisfy it — and that includes customer testimonials the manufacturer selected and published on its own site. A hand-picked quote on a commercial page is not an owner report anyone else can check.
Acceptable sources are venues the subject doesn't control: owner forums, long-term review posts, r/BuyItForLife and similar, dated first-person accounts. Where only manufacturer-hosted testimony exists, the score reflects that weakness and the claim says so.
Default weights
Parts availability and repairability determine whether a thing actually survives. A warranty is a promise; owner longevity is evidence. These defaults are a starting point, not a fixed rule — each category tunes its own weights against these defaults (see below).
| Dimension | Default weight |
|---|---|
| Warranty | 15% |
| Parts Availability | 25% |
| Repairability | 25% |
| Company Stability | 15% |
| Owner Longevity | 20% |
Per-category weights
Weights are stored per category because they should differ — resoleability dominates footwear, warranty dominates hand tools. Changing a weight is a visible, dated event: it happens in the data, and this page always reflects the live values.
Footwear
| Dimension | Weight |
|---|---|
| Warranty | 10% |
| Parts Availability | 25% |
| Repairability | 30% |
| Company Stability | 15% |
| Owner Longevity | 20% |
Bags & Backpacks
| Dimension | Weight |
|---|---|
| Warranty | 15% |
| Parts Availability | 25% |
| Repairability | 25% |
| Company Stability | 15% |
| Owner Longevity | 20% |
Hand Tools
| Dimension | Weight |
|---|---|
| Warranty | 25% |
| Parts Availability | 25% |
| Repairability | 20% |
| Company Stability | 15% |
| Owner Longevity | 15% |
Cookware
| Dimension | Weight |
|---|---|
| Warranty | 15% |
| Parts Availability | 25% |
| Repairability | 20% |
| Company Stability | 10% |
| Owner Longevity | 30% |
Kitchen Knives
| Dimension | Weight |
|---|---|
| Warranty | 20% |
| Parts Availability | 25% |
| Repairability | 25% |
| Company Stability | 10% |
| Owner Longevity | 20% |
Kitchen Appliances
| Dimension | Weight |
|---|---|
| Warranty | 20% |
| Parts Availability | 25% |
| Repairability | 25% |
| Company Stability | 15% |
| Owner Longevity | 15% |
Garden Tools
| Dimension | Weight |
|---|---|
| Warranty | 20% |
| Parts Availability | 25% |
| Repairability | 25% |
| Company Stability | 15% |
| Owner Longevity | 15% |
Camping Gear
| Dimension | Weight |
|---|---|
| Warranty | 15% |
| Parts Availability | 25% |
| Repairability | 25% |
| Company Stability | 15% |
| Owner Longevity | 20% |
Workwear
| Dimension | Weight |
|---|---|
| Warranty | 15% |
| Parts Availability | 25% |
| Repairability | 25% |
| Company Stability | 15% |
| Owner Longevity | 20% |
What the publish gate proves, and what it doesn't
The gate checks citation presence, not pertinence. It proves every dimension has a source attached; it cannot prove the source is actually about that dimension. Judging whether a quote supports a number is editorial work, not something a database constraint can express.
Seeding the first three products surfaced exactly this. One product scored 8 for owner longevity on a quote that was manufacturer marketing copy containing no longevity evidence at all. Another scored company stability on puffery, while the acquisition history that actually justified the number sat in an untagged source the score could not point at. Both passed the gate.
What the structure does buy is that the evidence is visible: every claim sits next to its quote and its URL on the product page, so a bad citation is reviewable rather than invisible. Treat the gate as a floor, and score review — a human reading quote against score before anything publishes — as the thing that actually protects the rubric.